How to Avoid the Biggest Legal Pitfalls in Collections

One wrong word in a collection call can cost you $1,000+ in fines. I've seen businesses destroyed by FDCPA violations they didn't even know they were committing.

After advising hundreds of businesses on collection compliance, here's the truth: most collection lawsuits are 100% preventable.

You don't need to be a lawyer. You just need to know the 10 biggest pitfalls and how to avoid them.

The FDCPA in 60 Seconds

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) protects consumers from abusive collection practices. While it technically applies to third-party collectors (not original creditors), many states have similar laws that DO apply to you.

Bottom line: Follow FDCPA guidelines even if you're the original creditor. It's the safest approach.

The 10 Deadly Pitfalls

Pitfall #1: Calling at the Wrong Time

The Rule: No calls before 8 AM or after 9 PM in the debtor's time zone. Common mistake: Calling at 7:45 PM your time, but it's 9:45 PM their time. The fix: Always confirm their time zone. Set CRM reminders that block calls outside 8 AM-9 PM their local time. Penalty: Up to $1,000 per violation

---

Pitfall #2: Calling Their Workplace After Being Told Not To

The Rule: If they say "don't call me at work," you MUST stop immediately. Common mistake: "But it's the only number I have!" The fix: Get their personal number. If they won't provide it, use mail or email only. Penalty: $1,000 per call after being told to stop

---

Pitfall #3: Threatening Action You Can't/Won't Take

Illegal threats:

"I'll have you arrested" (debt isn't a crime)

"We'll garnish your wages" (not without a judgment)

"I'll take your house" (not without legal process)

"I'll tell your employer" (that's defamation)

The fix: Only state consequences you can LEGALLY and ACTUALLY pursue:

✅ Legal: "If payment isn't received, we may file a lawsuit to obtain a judgment."

❌ Illegal: "Pay now or I'm calling the police."

Penalty: $1,000+ per threat, plus potential defamation lawsuit

---

Pitfall #4: Harassing or Abusive Language

What counts as harassment:

Profanity or obscene language

Threats of violence

Repeated calls intended to annoy (calling 10x/day)

Publishing the debt (posting on social media, telling neighbors)

The fix: Professional language ALWAYS. Even if they curse at you, you stay clean. How many calls is "too many"?

1-2 calls/day = generally okay

5-7 calls/day = harassment territory

10+ calls/day = clear violation

Penalty: $1,000+ per incident

---

Pitfall #5: Failing to Provide Debt Validation

The Rule: Within 5 days of first contact, you must send written notice including:

Amount owed

Creditor's name

Statement of their right to dispute within 30 days

Statement that you'll provide validation if they dispute

Common mistake: Making calls but never sending the validation letter. The fix: Automated validation letter goes out same day as first contact. Penalty: Entire debt could be deemed unenforceable

---

Pitfall #6: Continuing Collection During Dispute Period

The Rule: If they dispute the debt in writing within 30 days, you MUST stop collection until you provide validation. Common mistake: "They're obviously lying, so I'll keep calling." The fix:

1. Stop ALL collection activity immediately

2. Send validation (invoice, contract, proof of debt)

3. Wait until they receive it before resuming

Penalty: $1,000 per contact during dispute period

---

Pitfall #7: Misrepresenting Who You Are

Illegal tactics:

Pretending to be a lawyer

Implying you're law enforcement

Using fake company names to sound official

Not identifying yourself and your company

The fix: Every call starts with:

> "This is [Your Name] from [Your Company] calling about an outstanding balance."

Penalty: $1,000+ per violation, possible criminal charges for impersonating officials

---

Pitfall #8: Discussing the Debt with Third Parties

The Rule: You can ONLY discuss the debt with:

The debtor

The debtor's spouse

The debtor's attorney

Your attorney

You CANNOT tell:

Their employer

Their family members (except spouse)

Their neighbors

Their friends

Anyone on social media

The fix: If someone else answers:

> "I'm calling for [Debtor Name]. Is this them? No? May I leave a message asking them to call me back?"

Do NOT say why you're calling.

Penalty: $1,000 per disclosure, plus potential defamation lawsuit

---

Pitfall #9: Reporting False Information to Credit Bureaus

The Rule: Anything you report must be accurate. If they dispute it, you must investigate. Common mistakes:

Reporting a debt they actually paid

Wrong amount

Wrong date

Failing to mark "disputed" when they dispute it

The fix: Triple-check before reporting. Document everything. Penalty: $1,000 per inaccurate report + potential damages

---

Pitfall #10: Ignoring Cease & Desist Requests

The Rule: If they send written notice to stop contacting them, you MUST stop (except to notify them of specific actions like filing suit). Common mistake: "But I need to get paid!" The fix:

Stop ALL contact immediately

You can still sue, report to credit bureaus, or sell the debt

You just can't CONTACT them anymore

Penalty: $1,000 per contact after cease & desist

Special Situations

Bankruptcy

If they mention bankruptcy:

1. STOP collection immediately

2. Verify with PACER (federal bankruptcy database)

3. File a proof of claim

4. Wait for bankruptcy court resolution

Continuing collection after bankruptcy filing = automatic stay violation = serious consequences

Military Service Members

SCRA (Servicemembers Civil Relief Act) provides extra protections:

Interest rate caps (6% max during active duty)

No default judgments without military affidavit

Delayed civil proceedings

The fix: Ask if they're active military. If yes, consult a lawyer before proceeding.

Deceased Debtors

You can ONLY contact:

The executor/administrator of the estate

The debtor's spouse (for joint debts only)

You CANNOT:

Harass family members

Imply they inherited the debt (they probably didn't)

Compliance Checklist

Before EVERY collection call:

[ ] Confirm time zone (8 AM-9 PM their time?)

[ ] Check if they've requested no workplace calls

[ ] Verify no cease & desist letter on file

[ ] Confirm no active bankruptcy

[ ] Have validation letter been sent?

[ ] If they disputed, has validation been provided?

During the call:

[ ] Identify yourself and your company

[ ] State purpose (collecting a debt)

[ ] Use professional language only

[ ] Make no threats you can't execute

[ ] Don't discuss with third parties

[ ] Document everything said

After the call:

[ ] Document date, time, what was said

[ ] Note any requests (cease contact, no workplace calls)

[ ] Update CRM with compliance notes

What to Do If You Mess Up

If you realize you violated FDCPA: 1. Stop immediately

Don't compound the error.

2. Consult a lawyer

Collection law attorney, not your cousin who does real estate.

3. Consider settling proactively

If the debtor hasn't sued yet, you might offer to forgive the debt in exchange for a release.

4. Fix your process

Whatever caused the violation, fix it so it doesn't happen again.

State-Specific Laws

FDCPA is federal. Many states have STRICTER laws:

California: Rosenthal Act (applies to original creditors) New York: Strict regulations on collection calls Texas: Finance Code restrictions Florida: Consumer Collection Practices Act The fix: Know YOUR state's laws or hire a collections attorney for guidance.

The Collection Kings Difference

We've conducted 10,000+ collections with ZERO legal complaints. How?

Our compliance system:

Every collector trained in FDCPA annually

Call recording and random audits

Automated compliance checks in our CRM

Legal review of all scripts and letters

Immediate cease & desist processing

Result: Maximum recovery with zero legal risk.

When to Hand Off to Professionals

You should outsource if:

You're making more than 50 collection calls/month

You've already made a mistake

You're not confident in compliance

The debtor has an attorney

The debtor mentioned bankruptcy

Why: Professional collectors know the law, have insurance, and take the legal risk off you. Ready to hand off risky accounts? Get a free assessment or contact us.

Key Takeaways

✅ Follow FDCPA even if you're the original creditor

✅ 8 AM-9 PM only (their time zone)

✅ Stop calling workplace if asked

✅ No threats you can't execute

✅ Professional language always

✅ Validation letter within 5 days

✅ Stop during 30-day dispute period

✅ Don't discuss debt with third parties

✅ Cease & desist = stop immediately

✅ Document EVERYTHING

Remember: One violation can cost $1,000+. Prevention is cheap. Lawsuits are expensive. Know the rules, follow them religiously, and you'll never have a problem.